Jump to content

Comparison Bananian


indus

Recommended Posts

I was using bananian for the last year(and I still do) on a M1 for a operational running webservice. Is it worth the time to switch to armbian? Are there any big differences?

 

I want to switch the board sometime in the future; thats why I'm interested in the more flexible armbian in the first place. But right now I cant find a good alternative to the M1 for my use case.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@indus, I've decided to go this route rather than bananian, as I'm looking for a distro that provides some 'commonality' across a number of SBC boards. For my current project a Banana Pi M1+ provides the hardware I require. I have plans for another SBC deployment within my (small) network, where a Raspberry Pi may be suitable and another where a Cubie may be best suited. 

 

Having a common distro across all these boards is why I chose this route.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Forum!

 

Just for the fun of it, i would like to upgrade a working bananian installation to armbian. Does anybody here know if the steps needed are already described somewhere?

 

Thanks for your time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i would like to upgrade a working bananian installation to armbian

 

Which Bananian version using which kernel?

 

Please provide the output of:

uname -a
cat /etc/bananian_platform
cat /etc/bananian_version
cat /etc/debian_version
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Even I made many tests ... backup is recommended.

 

Backup is highly recommended when trying to crossgrade from Bananian I would suspect?

 

At least sources.list should also be adjusted and an 'aptitude purge u-boot-bananian' before? Since otherwise 'apt-get upgrade' will create a mess?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Backup is highly recommended when trying to crossgrade from Bananian I would suspect?

 

At least sources.list should also be adjusted and an 'aptitude purge u-boot-bananian' before? Since otherwise 'apt-get upgrade' will create a mess?

 

Or from any other systems, yes.

 

I am removing their sources.list but am not sure for all custom packages. In any case, they are not updating anymore if list is gone ...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"icon_exclaim.gifBananian will not boot on your Banana Pi M1, M1+, Pro and R1 any longer icon_exclaim.gif"

 

Ouch!

 

No, not that. Only the possible Bananian package is not updating any more if upgraded to Armbian.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"icon_exclaim.gifBananian will not boot on your Banana Pi M1, M1+, Pro and R1 any longer icon_exclaim.gif"

 

This is just a quote from https://www.bananian.org/bananapi-m2#migrate_from_banana_pi_m1_m1_pro_and_r1(and true of course when you exchange the bootloader stuff for a different SoC). Anyway: I still would first check which hardware and which Debian/kernel version we're talking about before thinking about an upgrade.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

 

the upgrade to Armbian worked for me from Bananian 15.04 Wheezy with Openmediavault 2 on Banana Pro without problems. The sources from Bananian were deleted automatically.

 

I've just followed Igor instructions.

 

Now I've Linux bananapi 3.4.110 sun7i.

 

I needed Sunxi sndi2s driver for my Beaunanas (a Banana Nas server boxed in a French Burgondy Beaune wine bottle box in wood  :)  ) to make working my DAC with MPD, missed driver on Bananian 15.04.

 

Thanks for Armbian ! :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I found Armbian more contemporary and more friendly out of the box:

  • systemd (yeah, I hate it as everybody else but this is just convenience if you had many other systems)
  • bash as a default shell (zsh is not my beast)
  • network configurations are easier to switch (symlinks in /etc/network)
  • boot partition already mounted in filesystem
  • more SBCs supported, makes hardware a commodity, the same distribution on many boards makes management easier (I have ~10 running 24/7 and another 3 - 4 occasionally)

Other than that I did not found many reasons to switch from Bananian to Armbian, YMMV.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use - Privacy Policy - Guidelines